The Hillman Letter. Monday, October 12, 2026.
Most clinics I review have a retention policy. Few have a retention practice. The gap shows up on the worst possible day: the day a subpoena or civil investigative demand arrives and someone asks, “What do we still have?”
The answer should take an hour. In too many practices it takes weeks, and the answer is “less than we thought.”
This issue covers what federal rules say you must keep, what changes once a dispute is on the horizon, and what an operator can fix this quarter.
Not legal advice. I am not an attorney. Retention periods and preservation duties turn on your facts, your state, and your payers. Work through counsel on any live matter.
Start with what you are already required to keep
Three federal anchors set a floor for most practices.
HIPAA Privacy Rule documentation. Under 45 CFR 164.530(j), a covered entity must keep its privacy policies and procedures, required written communications, and records of required actions and designations. The retention period is six years from creation or from the date the item was last in effect, whichever is later. That covers things like your privacy official designation, training records, complaint logs, and sanctions.
HIPAA Security Rule documentation. 45 CFR 164.316(b)(2)(i) applies the same six-year clock to security policies and to records of required actions, activities, and assessments. Your risk analysis counts. So does the documentation behind each policy revision.
One trap: these HIPAA sections govern compliance documentation. They do not set a retention period for the medical record itself. State law and payer contracts do that. I still see policies that say “we keep charts six years per HIPAA.” That sentence is wrong, and opposing counsel will notice.
Medicare ordering and referral records. 42 CFR 424.516(f) requires providers and suppliers that furnish covered ordered, certified, referred, or prescribed Part A or B services, items, or drugs to keep that documentation for seven years from the date of service. The same applies to the physician or eligible professional who did the ordering. The records include written orders, certifications, referrals, prescriptions, and requests for payment. On request, you must give CMS or a Medicare contractor access.
Seven years from date of service is not seven years from the end of the fiscal year. If your purge job runs on fiscal-year logic, check the math.
Then layer on the duty to preserve
A retention schedule tells you the minimum. A preservation duty tells you to stop deleting, period.
Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 37(e) addresses electronically stored information that “should have been preserved in the anticipation or conduct of litigation” and is lost because a party “failed to take reasonable steps to preserve it.” If the data cannot be restored or replaced, the court can order measures to cure prejudice. If the court finds intent to deprive the other side of the information, it can presume the lost data was unfavorable, instruct the jury to presume the same, or enter dismissal or default.
Read the trigger carefully. It says anticipation of litigation. Not service of a complaint. A demand letter, a payer audit with recoupment language, a terminated employee who says “my lawyer will be in touch,” or a CID can all start the clock. Counsel decides when the duty attached. Operations has to be able to act the same day.
OIG says the same thing from the compliance side. In its General Compliance Program Guidance (November 2023), under Element 7, Responding to Detected Offenses and Developing Corrective Action Initiatives, OIG states that “the compliance officer or counsel should take appropriate steps to secure or prevent the destruction of documents or other evidence relevant to the investigation.” It also says a contemporaneous record of each internal investigation should be kept, including a log of witnesses interviewed and documents reviewed.
That guidance is voluntary and nonbinding. It is also the yardstick a government reviewer will hold up next to your program.
Where clinics actually lose data
In my work through retaining counsel, the losses are rarely dramatic. The data leaks out through routine settings nobody remembered to pause:
Email auto-delete set to 90 days on a hosted mailbox.
Text messages on personal phones used to coordinate scheduling, referrals, or patient questions.
Phone system voicemail that rolls off after 30 days.
A departed manager’s laptop wiped and reissued within a week.
A billing system migration where the old vendor’s export was “good enough.”
Shared drive folders cleaned up by a well-meaning office manager.
Each one is defensible on a normal Tuesday. Each one looks bad once the duty to preserve attached and nobody turned it off.
What a working hold looks like
A hold is not a memo. It is a short process with an owner.
Trigger. Counsel decides a hold is warranted and defines scope: matter, date range, custodians, systems.
Suspend. Operations pauses auto-delete, purge jobs, device reimaging, and voicemail rollover for the scoped custodians and systems. Same day.
Notify. Each custodian gets a plain-language hold notice and signs an acknowledgment. Include personal devices if they were used for work.
Log. Someone keeps a running record: who was notified, when, what was suspended, and any exceptions.
Refresh. Reissue the notice on a set cadence and whenever scope changes or a new custodian is identified.
Release. Only counsel lifts the hold, in writing. Then normal retention resumes.
Steps 2 and 4 fail most often. They belong to IT and operations, not legal. If nobody in operations knows how to suspend your email retention rule, find out now.
Operator checklist
Retention schedule lists each record type, the governing rule, the clock start, and the system of record.
HIPAA compliance documentation is kept six years from creation or last effective date (45 CFR 164.316(b)(2)(i); 164.530(j)(2)).
Medicare order, referral, certification, and prescription documentation is kept seven years from date of service (42 CFR 424.516(f)).
Medical record retention follows state law and payer contracts, and the policy says so.
Every automated deletion setting is inventoried, with a named person who can pause it.
A hold notice template and acknowledgment form exist and have been reviewed by counsel.
Offboarding checks for active holds before any device is wiped or account is closed.
Work texting on personal phones is either banned in practice or captured.
Each internal investigation has a contemporaneous file with a witness and document log.
This takes an owner, a list, and a test run. Pick a fake matter, issue a mock hold, and time how long it takes to freeze every system. That number tells you more about your exposure than any policy binder.
Andrew Jonathan Hillman / Dallas. Healthcare operations and regulatory operator. Expert witness retained through counsel. Senior paralegal. Not an attorney. This Letter is not legal advice.


